About African Americans & the Presidency Black Politics Today Videos Biographies of Presidents Research Resources Articles and Briefs

Must Reads


Jeff Sessions, Eric Holder and Mass Black Incarceration -- Revisited and Revised Black Agenda Report



Black-Hating Negroes and Their Uses: David Clarke at Homeland SecurityBlack Agenda Report


Karen Spellman and the SNCC Legacy Project, Black Power ChronicleBlack Agenda Report


Nina Turner on Firing of Cleveland Cop Who Killed Tamir Rice, The Real News

Top Climate Scientist, Journalist & Activists Blast Trump's Withdrawal from Paris Accord, Democracy Now


Shooters of Color Are Called 'Terrorists' and 'Thugs.' Why Are White Shooters Called 'Mentally Ill'? Common Dreams


Take Down the Confederate Flag, Now Common Dreams


Remembering President Wilson's Purge of Black Federal Workers Talking Points Memo


Blood money, killer cops: How privatization is funding the racist logic of America's police Salon


The New Hillary CounterPunch


Hillary Clinton: the Savior That Wasn't CounterPunch


Galeano Died CounterPunch


Kobach Defends Remark On Obama Not Prosecuting Black Criminals Talking Points Memo


Erick Erickson: Everything Obama Does Is To 'Humble The Arrogant Crackers' Talking Points Memo


Food and water deprivation, abuse and overcrowding in Michigan's women's prison World Socialist Website


The Rainbow Sign CounterPunch


Netanyahu's Victory is an Even Bigger Victory for Palestinian Solidarity Movement CounterPunch


Sundown in Indiana CounterPunch


Alabama Ex-Cop Indicted For Body Slamming Indian Grandfather Talking Points Memo


Endless War: As US Strikes Tikrit and Delays Afghan Pullout, 'War on Terror' Toll Tops 1.3 Million TruthOut


Those Crappy Trade Deals CounterPunch


Is John Boehner a Traitor? TruthOut


State of the Black Union: The Shadow of Crisis Has Not Passed TruthOut


Hope Dies Last: Obama's SOTU Platitudes CounterPunch


Obama's Had a Helluva Good Month Since the Midterms Mother Jones


GOPer Mia Love: Time 'To Move On' From Scalise's Hate Group Speech Talking Points Memo


The Battle of Our Time: Breaking the Spell of the Corporate State Common Dreams


Police Brutality and the Failure of Liberal Democrats TruthOut


When the United States Government Broke Relations with Cuba CounterPunch


Obama Takes Care of Business CounterPunch


The New Civil Rights Movement CounterPunch


The Unenviable Fate of the Bhopal Gas Victims CounterPunch


Chicago could lose out on presidential library Politico


The Faces of Senior Poverty Are Likely Women of Color Common Dreams


Never Convicted, but Held Back by a Criminal Record Talk Poverty


It's Time for an Executive Order to Ban the Box Talk Poverty


The Long History of Presumed White Innocence and Black Guilt TruthOut


Charter Schools May Actually Be Re-Segregating America's School System In These Times


Tavis Smiley Offers A Surprising Opinion About The President That Even Smiley's Staunchest Critics Will Have Trouble Disagreeing With Atlanta Black Star


Why Texas Is Shutting Prison Doors TruthOut


Africa Now November 12, 2014 Afro-Brazilians and the Recent Elections in Brazil Africa Now


States Project 3 Percent Increase in Prisoners by 2018 Pew Trusts


The Climate Crisis is Capitalism CounterPunch


The Gloating of the Neocons CounterPunch


ISIS: the Useful Enemy CounterPunch


A Civil War Without End CounterPunch


The Case Against Labor-Market Individualism CounterPunch


Ebola, Capitalism and the Idea of Society CounterPunch


The Humanism of Ali Mazrui CounterPunch


The 'Medicine' of the Trans-Pacific Partnership CounterPunch


The Black-Brown Alliance That's Turning Kansas Blue In These Times


William Rivers Pitt | The Iraq War Was a Smashing Success TruthOut


Think Tanks as Lobbyists: US Groups Receive Millions to Push Foreign Nations' AgendasTruthOut


ISIS and the American Way of War CounterPunch


Oklahoma Gov. Will Skip Local GOP Fundraiser With KKK Discussion Talking Points Memo


On Ferguson, No Words From Hillary Clinton Politico


Fast-Food Workers Challenge Stereotypes, Globalize Question of Fairness TruthOut


Oklahoma Gov. Will Skip Local GOP Fundraiser With KKK Discussion Talking Points Memo


The Master's House Is Burning: bell hooks, Cornel West and the Tyranny of Neoliberalism Truth-Out


Georgia Immigrant Detainees 'Riot' Over Maggot-Filled Food Colorlines


Remembering Vincent Harding, an Enduring Veteran of Hope Truth-Out


Justice Department to Begin Collecting Racial Profiling Data Colorlines

Nation's Oldest Black-Owned Bookstore Gets Evicted Colorlines


Angela Y. Davis on what's radical in the 21st century Los Angeles Times


Even With Obamacare, Many Latinos Still Seek Treatment In Mexico Kaiser Health News


When Corporations Get Too Big to Tax TruthOut


Challenging the Ruling Economic Orthodoxy CounterPunch


Ted Cruz: John Kerry should step down Politico


Kerry's Apartheid Comments Provoke Political Storm The Daily Beast

Why There Is No Cure for the GOP's Benghazi Fever Mother Jones


Mississippi Senate Candidate Backs Out Of Keynoting Gun Rally Billed With White Nationalist Talking Points Memo


New Rule Prohibits Voters In Miami-Dade County From Using The Restroom, No Matter How Long The Line Think Progress


Are Black "Success Stories" Really Holding Us Back? Black Agenda Report

GA Dem Guv Candidate: We Can't Stop Confederate License Plates Talking Points Memo


No Rush in Ethiopia to Pry Misery from the Mirage of Capitalism, News Junkie Post


African Refugees Not Welcome: Xenophobia and Intolerance as Policy, News Junkie Post


Water and Soil, Grain and Flesh:Walter Johnson Reconsiders the Connection Between Slavery and Capitalism, The Nation


Obama's Iraq Fairy Tale, CounterPunch


Henry Giroux- Beyond Neoliberal Miseducation TruthOut


Obama Library Planning Push Moves Into Next Stage, Politico


Obama's Iraq Fairy Tale, CounterPunch


The Massive Policy Failure That Paul Ryan Wants To Emulate Think Progress

Paul Ryan: There's An Inner City 'Culture Problem' Of Men Not Working Talking Points Memo

Rep. Lee: Ryan's 'Inner City' Remarks A 'Racial Attack' Talking Points Memo

Why There's an Even Larger Racial Disparity in Private Prisons Than in Public Ones, MotherJones

Virginia Conservatives Shoot Down Obamacare's Medicaid Expansion, Talking Points Memo

The Poisons of Extreme Wealth and Inequality, TruthOut

"The Militant Mystery of World War I, CounterPunch

On Fred Korematsu Day: From Evacuation to Deportation on the Anniversary of Japanese-American Internment TruthOut

Rage Against the Dying of a Light: Stuart Hall (1932-2014) TruthOut

"Operation Afro-Dilution": Michigan's Plan to Flood Detroit with Upscale Immigrants, Black Agenda Report

The Budget Deal and Neo-liberals, CounterPunch

President James Garfield: Reconciling North and South

I have never been anything else than radical on all these questions of Freedom and Slavery, rebellion and the War. I have had neither inclination or motive to be otherwise . . .--James Garfield

The notion that the Civil War was God’s response to the sin of enslaving blacks appealed to future president James A. Garfield during his prime. “For what else are we so fearfully scourged and defeated?,” he once asked. Descended from the Puritan Edward Garfield who arrived in America in 1635, James Garfield’s early American ancestors were among the successive generations that battled Indians to expand the borders of the colonies. James Abram Garfield was born on November 19, 1831 in a log cabin near Mentor, Ohio to Abram Garfield and Eliza Ballou. When he was only eighteen months old, his father died after catching a cold putting out a forest fire leaving him to be raised by his mother and an uncle. Poverty-stricken and underprivileged he became a voracious reader and compensated for his background by a gritty determination.

Early in life, Garfield joined a religious cult, the “Disciples.” Sharing an evolving doctrine that at times included a radical egalitarian tendency, they split over the issue of slavery. In defending his position, he wrote in his diary, “The simple relation of master and slave is not unchristian (sic).” Most of the local followers in the Case Western Reserve area, however, opposed slavery and Garfield began to oppose slavery in word, as well as in deed, during this period. Once Garfield hid a desperate African American fugitive who had escaped from slavery in the South and helped him on his way to Canada. On another occasion, Garfield organized a group of men determined to rescue by force what he believed to be two African fugitives from slavery that had been recaptured and were being held. As it turned out the incident was merely a college prank, but Garfield’s sentiments and conviction were apparently genuine. Nevertheless, he remained opposed to abolitionism as he refused to allow an abolitionist rally to be held at a meeting house commenting, “(W)hile I stay here, the school shall never be given over to an overheated and brainless faction.” Later, Garfield was termed by a political opponent on campus “the prince of slaveholders and plotters.” Throughout his career Garfield seemed to have mixed feelings on the subjects of African Americans, democracy, and civil rights.

With the emergence of the Republican Party, Garfield became involved campaigning for John C. Fremont in 1856. Despite his ambivalent emotions with respect to African Americans, Garfield later became an ally of the progressive forces represented by Thaddeus Stevens and other Radical Republicans. An adaptive politician during his liberal phase, the young congressman declared, “I say here, before this House, that I will never so long as I have any voice in political affairs, rest satisfied until the way is opened by which these colored people, as soon as they are worthy, shall be lifted to the full rights of citizenship.” In Garfield’s inaugural speech, he bluntly stated that there “can be no permanent disfranchised peasantry in the United States.”

The evolution of James Garfield’s thought with respect to African Americans and their civil rights was deeply impacted by his experiences during the Civil War. From the outset he viewed the war as an anti-slavery effort, although he knew firsthand the burning hatred many of the union officers harbored toward blacks. As he witnessed what he termed the deep hostility of the Southerners he met and officers whom he felt were not working to win the war as they felt it would end slavery, his political thought evolved. As the war progressed Garfield said he found himself “coming nearer and nearer to downright Abolitionism” eventually reaching the conclusion that slavery being the cause of the war, its destruction must be an outcome of the war. He took as a “solemn oath” that slavery must be destroyed as a God-sanctioned task. During the high point of Garfield’s sentiment opposing slavery he also believed that the elimination of slave owners as a class was a necessary step towards justice and peace. Clearly, at this stage in his career he demonstrated unusual sympathy with the victims of slavery. Once, Garfield was said to have angrily rejected a commanding officers order to hunt for a fugitive slave that had entered his camp telling the general to do it himself. During the war Garfield supported the arming of blacks as soldiers dismissing fears that this move might spark black slave insurrections. It would be bloody, Garfield responded, “but it is not in my heart to lay a feather’s weight in the way of our Black Americans if they choose to strike for what was always their own.”

By 1865, Garfield’s position on black emancipation had hardened, leading to more stridency in his presentations on the issue. His strong sense of spirituality during this period helped him conclude then that the Civil War was God’s retribution for America’s sin of slavery. “For what else are we so fearfully scourged and defeated?,” Garfield once asked. Following the war, Garfield supported voting rights, and also introduced a resolution that would have ended the requirement that African-Americans in the District of Columbia blacks carry passes.

Soon, however, Garfield’s progressive policies began to moderate. By 1870, Garfield heralded the “triumphant conclusion” of the fight against slavery with the passage of the 15th Amendment giving blacks the right to vote. Now, Providence placed “upon the African Race the care of its own destiny. It places their fortune in their own hands.” Eager to reconcile with white Southerners, Garfield wanted to declare victory and move on to other issues. Like Hayes, he began to view former southern Whigs as the best guarantors of black civil rights. At bottom, these Republicans desired to build up a southern branch of their party at the expense of African Americans in the party and in the region. A white southern party would make the Republican Party a truly national party and presumably move beyond mere racial issues to issues they regarded as worthy of national attention. The goal was a situation in which black “constitutional rights,” or lack thereof, would not be threatened by one party’s or the other’s dominance and a situation in which men of the “south as in the north men” could unite around what they view as the “great commercial and industrial questions rather than on questions of race and color.”

Not coincidentally, Garfield came to advocate “states rights:” and, therefore, pleaded that the federal government was unable to respond to the wave of anti-black terrorism plaguing the South. Despite this, as late as 1878, Garfield chided President Hayes for his generosity to the white South saying his policies had “turned out to be a give-away from the beginning.” Upon accepting the Republican nomination for president, Garfield’s message gave African Americans cause to hope that his administration would mark a change from the policies of conciliation. Garfield maintained at the time that the South could only prosper when all voters could “freely and safely support the party he pleases.” In planning the 1880 campaign, the top


President James Garfield

James Abram Garfield, 20th President

March 4, 1881 to September 19, 1881

Birth: November 19, 1831, Moreland Hllls, Ohio

Death: September 19, 1881

Education: Hiram College, Williams College

Religion: Churches of Christ

Profession: Lawyer, Teacher, Lay Preacher

Political Party: Republican

Primary Form of Relationship with African Americans: Politician

Important Online Works

Life Portrait of James Garfield Jul 26, 1999 CSPAN



strategists of the Republican Party met in New York City at the Fifth Avenue Hotel August 5th, 6th, and 7th. Former Governor Pinckney B.S. Pinchback dramatically told the assembled Republican leaders that in many areas African Americans were lynched in they attempted to vote and urged that well-known Republican leaders tour the South to reinforce the legal rights of those threatened with disfranchisement. Pinchback’s New Orleans Weekly Louisianian, however, rejected Garfield’s statement that African Americans represent the sole source of ignorance in the South. This logic, the editorial stated, “is the shoal upon which the South is likely to be wrecked, unless the National Government come to its aid.” The editorial cited the “the hoards of white children growing up in utter ignorance and depravity in the South. . . .” as an important concern.

During the campaign for president, the candidate Garfield testified to his love of blacks’ loyalty to the union, “we have seen white man betray the flag and fight to kill the Union, but in all that long, dreary war, we never [saw] a traitor in black skin.” He vowed that “now that we have made them free, so long as we live, we will stand by the black citizens. . . . We will stand by them until the sun of liberty fixed in the firmament of our constitution shall shine with equal rays upon every man, white or black, throughout the Union."

Yet, in Garfield’s emotional flip-flops Frederick Douglass and other black leaders found a resurfacing of anti-black sentiment. Their suspicions were well-founded. Although Garfield had backed black suffrage, he confided privately in 1865 that he had, “a strong feeling of repugnance when I think of the negro (sic) being made our political equal and I would be glad if they could be colonized, sent to heaven, or got rid of in any decent way. . . “ lamenting that “colonization has proved a hopeless failure everywhere.” Garfield also once complained that Capital Hill was “infested with Negroes.” Behind Garfield’s transformation was the pressure of the business community, especially in key cities such as Cincinnati where protests and boycotts by southern consumers of local goods and products were beginning to hurt. Several companies laid off workers leading businesses to unite to protest a key Republican newspapers’ perceived anti-southern content. Republican businessmen were among those pressuring leading Republicans toward a more conciliatory and tolerant policy toward the South.

In December 1880, shortly after his election as president, but prior to his inauguration, Garfield sought to replace Frederick Douglass as Marshal of the United States for the District of Columbia. Douglass wrote Garfield requesting that he be reappointed voicing his conviction that “. . . whatever may be the ostensible reasons given for it, the real ground of opposition to me is that I am a colored man, and that my sympathies are with my recently enslaved people.” Douglass mobilized some support for his reappointment, notably author Mark Twain who wrote a supporting letter Garfield. Later, Garfield informed Douglass that he wanted to appoint one of his close friends as U. S. Marshal and that, instead, he would appoint Douglass as Recorder of Deeds for the District of Columbia.

Unprecedented numbers of African Americans attended Garfield’s inauguration ball. Garfield appointed black leaders to the “Negro” jobs within his administration. Blanche K. Bruce was appointed Registrar of the Treasury, John Mercer Langston was named Minister to Haiti and Consul General to the Dominican Republic, and Henry Highland Garnet was appointed to the post of the Minister to Liberia. On balance, however, the brief administration of President James A. Garfield merely continued the policy of fostering sectional reconciliation at the expense of black civil rights that had gathered momentum during the Hayes administration.

The most striking fact with respect to Garfield’s presidency was its brevity. In July 1881 he was assassinated by Charles Guiteau in Washington, D. C. After struggling for life for seventy-nine agonizing days, Garfield succumbed to his wounds.
©Christopher Brian Booker, 2014.